An online discussion has erupted regarding the retention of NYSC corps members after a worker revealed that colleagues largely dismissed a high-achieving member due to her demeanor.
The source explains that two female NYSC participants are stationed at the same office, and management intends to keep only one once their service year ends.
Consequently, the HR team was asked to gather staff opinions before formulating a recommendation.
One participant is noted for her amiable, respectful nature and is popular among coworkers, whereas the other, despite delivering strong results in marketing and securing a business deal, has gained a reputation for discourtesy.
HR Requests Staff Feedback Prior to Retention Decision
The employee described the dilemma confronting management: weighing outstanding performance against harmonious workplace relations.
Although the courteous corps member is still mastering her duties, several colleagues feel she can develop further with appropriate mentorship.
She stated, “We have two female NYSC corps members serving in our office. One is exceptionally friendly, greets everyone, gets along with the team, and is genuinely enjoyable to work with. The other often behaves rudely; staff regularly complain about her attitude. Since they will soon complete their service, HR has been tasked with evaluating them because leadership wishes to retain only one individual.”
Discussion Ignites Over Attitude Versus Performance
The narrative has sparked debate on whether employers should prioritize skill or character when deciding who to keep.
Many commentators argued that technical abilities can be taught through training, whereas a negative attitude may persistently undermine collaboration and morale.
Others contended that organizations often secure superior long-term outcomes by retaining workers who exhibit professionalism, respect, and eagerness to learn, even if they need initial upskilling.
The episode continues to fuel conversation about the traits employers value beyond quantifiable performance.
See the screenshot below:
About the Author
